Counter-Heritage

The Ironbridge Gorge World Heritage Site

‘The most extraordinary district in the world’ We have just had a wonderful and truly memorable visit (early November 2026 – last here forty years ago) to Ironbridge, Blists Hill and Coalbrookdale. As a National Trust member, I thought I might pen a few lines about how moved I have been so as to contribute to the conversations about the evolution of the site. I think it was seeing the N.T.’s mission statement about, “Addressing barriers that prevent people engaging with heritage. We will continue to deepen the sites’ strong appeal for people through visitor experience and storytelling that brings history to life’ that particularly inspired me: a heartwarming address. And then another: ‘We want to understand how people would like to experience and get involved … and will be taking time to listen to you. We’ll be working with communities and visitors to build on the museums’ legacies and help shape what the future of Ironbridge Gorge National Trust looks like. This is the start of a long-term vision for the future.’ One further mission statement before I pen a response in the tone and spirit requested: ‘Ironbridge Gorge National Trust could be a place … of ideas and inspiration. We aim to bring together parties, local industries and creative enterprises to make past achievements relevant to today. We hope to inspire everyone, especially children and young people to become the innovators of the future.’ Those words and my visits to the three sites mentioned in the first paragraph have led to five points that I shall pursue in something of a disquisition: Trades Unionism and...
Sub. Rooms: Theatre of Memories

Sub. Rooms: Theatre of Memories

Public buildings are not just about accounts, ledgers and money,
They are also about what Raphael Samuel called ‘Theatres of Memory’,
Where varying conceptions of ‘Heritage’ can collude, collide, or elide:
If each of us could walk alone through the Subscription Rooms,
Alone in memory, reverie and seasonal darkness,
As the clock, Jacob Marley-like, chimed through the night,
What a miscellany of ghosts of Stroud Subscription Rooms’ past
Would be invoked!
Those concerts, those bands, those exhibitions, those meetings,
Those queues, the café, the bar,
Tickets for shows and the National Express bus …

read more
Dennis Severs’ House

Dennis Severs’ House

It’s like History on Acid,
A Raphael Samuel Magical Mystery Tour,
Not Seven Rooms of Gloom,
But ten rooms which haunt and hex:
The dead still alive,
Watching us trip through space and time,
Jonathan Wild and Jack Sheppard outside,
Peering through the window panes,
Observing us in our candle-lit dream,
Clocks ticking away the century
Until it’s the time for Jacob Marley
To makes his visitation and warning,
Not just to Ebenezer Scrooge,

read more
The Glade

The Glade

In The Glade

Anne Creed has transformed the derelict waste land off Nelson Street into a place of beauty, special to many. A broken piece of roofing slate on the corner of the Golden Fleece carved with the word glade in Tom Perkins style marks the entrance and points to the cracked pool table inscribed with ‘Song’ by Ivor Gurney.

Only the wanderer knows England’s graces

Or can anew see clear familiar faces

And who loves joy as he who dwells in shadows

Do not forget me, quite, O Severn meadows

Gurney wrote it on the Western Front in the spring of 1917 before the Third Battle of Ypres (Passchendaele) where he was gassed. Broken in two, the slate was dumped in a skip. The break could represent the breakup of Europe in the First World War or the subsequent break down of his mental health.

“No it’s the River Severn,” a friend said.

read more
Before The Luddites

Before The Luddites

Before the Luddites Custom, community and machinery in the English woollen industry, 1776-1809

Adrian Randall CUP

This wonderful book opens with an exploration of the pejorative use of the term ‘Luddites’ – they were right weren’t they? Wages did fall and goods could deteriorate – and how they ‘could little have imagined the linguistic legacy they were to bequeath to posterity.’ Randall points out that a focus upon direct action – rioting and so on – does not ‘accentuate’ the ‘atypical’: ‘riots often provide historians with our only point of access’ into the past values, attitudes and traditions of custom-held rights. And this point of access reveals that ‘Resistance to machinery was multiform … peaceful petitioning, appeals to the courts … negotiations … strike action, intimidation and riot.’ Randall shows how this resistance echoed 18th century Gloucestershire food riots – ‘Just as food riots reveal order, discrimination and a clear moral economy, so do the community-based riots against the jenny and scribbling machine.’

read more
The View from the Rock

The View from the Rock

The View From The Rock in NYC The sign said that you could ‘Travel anywhere free in Manhattan for ten dollars’, The best example of Marcusian unification of opposites, Marxian false consciousness, and oxymoronic logic I’ve seen anywhere; But those advertisements help...

read more